I am an UI armchair quarterback at best, but two things about this Messages icon bother me:
1) Aqua (and these blue stripes in particular) is on the way out. What is it doing here?
2) The ellipsis (. . .) In the smaller bubble is misleading. In iOS iMessage AND OS X iChat before it, ellipsis indicate that someone is typing. It’s the precursor to a notification. When people see it, the user has an expectation that something is coming soon in that application. By putting an ellipsis in a static icon, the user is misled.
Leave a Reply